Nightly Fasting Found Beneficial to Reduce Breast Cancer Recurrence
A study of more than 2400 women with early-stage breast cancer has found that those who fasted 13 hours or more at night reduced their risk of breast cancer recurrence, findings that suggest prolonging the nightly fasting interval may offer a relatively safe nonpharmacologic way for women with early breast cancer to lower their risk of disease recurrence.
Laura Newton Rutledge, MA RD
A study of more than 2400 women with early-stage breast cancer has found that those who fasted 13 hours or more at night reduced their risk of breast cancer recurrence, findings that suggest prolonging the nightly fasting interval may offer a relatively safe nonpharmacologic way for women with early breast cancer to lower their risk of disease recurrence.1
Nightly fasting less than 13 hours was not significantly associated with a higher risk of breast cancer mortality.
The patient cohort for this study was drawn from participants in the Women’s Healthy Eating and Living (WHEL) study conducted between 1995 and 2007. This randomized, controlled trial involved 3088 women with early-stage invasive breast cancer and evaluated whether a low-fat diet focused on vegetables, fruit, and fiber reduced breast cancer recurrence risk and mortality.
The present study looked at invasive breast cancer recurrence and new primary breast tumors during an average of 7.3 years of follow-up and death from breast cancer or any cause during an average 11.4 years of surveillance.
Data were gathered from the participants’ telephone self-reports of their recall of their dietary patterns over the previous 24hours, taken at baseline, year 1, and year 4.
Participants were aged a median 52.4 years. They reported a mean fasting duration of 12.5 hours per night and 4.4 eating episodes, defined as the number of times per day that they consumed ≥25 kcal at a single time point. Approximately 33% of participants reported eating episodes after 8 pm.
A nightly fast of less than 13 hours was associated with a 36% higher risk of breast cancer recurrence, compared with fasting ≥13 hours per night. Additionally, each 2-hour increase in nightly fasting was associated with significantly lower hemoglobin A1C levels.
Another interesting research finding involved sleep quality: the investigators found that prolonged fasting at night was associated with longer sleep duration, a finding in line with previous research that consuming foods late at night may interfere with circadian rhythms.
The authors noted that limited data exist from previous small studies involving humans that signal a positive impact from intermittent fasting regimens on risk factors for poor breast cancer outcomes, among them, glucose regulation, inflammation, obesity, and sleep.
“Our study introduces a novel dietary strategy and indicates that prolonging the length of the nightly fasting interval could be a simple and feasible strategy to reduce breast cancer recurrence,” the authors wrote. “In this cohort of patients with early-stage breast cancer, a longer nightly fasting interval was also associated with significantly lower concentrations of hemoglobin A1C and longer sleep duration.”
The researchers concluded that although the study findings “have broad and significant implications for public health, randomized trials are needed to adequately test whether prolonging the nightly fasting interval can reduce the risk of chronic disease.”
Oncology Nursing News asked Advisory Board member Laura Newton Rutledge, MA RD, assistant professor in the Department of Health Nutrition Sciences at the University of Birmingham in Alabama to offer her perspective on the research.
Nutrition research in cancer has primarily focused on what people eat in relation to cancer, but this article lends weight to also focus on when and how often people eat. A variety of fasting-type diets are currently being studied in relation to cancer, weight control, and other chronic diseases. In these studies, fasting is often defined as: intermittent energy restriction (IER), which involves fasting or greatly reduced (<500 calories/day) food intake intermittently, for example 2 days a week or every other day; or time-restricted feeding (TRF), which involves limiting intake of food to a set time window. Interestingly, the Marinac study found a correlation between a 13-hour fast and breast cancer recurrence while most time-controlled studies limit food intake to a 4-6 hour time window.Obesity is a known risk factor for many types of cancer and breast cancer recurrence. For many years, nutrition advice has focused on the benefits of a plant-based diet emphasizing vegetables and fruits and including fish and nuts, along with the mantra to eat 3 meals/day with small snacks to reduce cancer risk and control weight. However, this pattern of frequent eating is abnormal from an evolutionary perspective, and recent research has shown that even skipping breakfast is not associated with weight gain.2 Focusing on the frequency and timing of meals may improve overall health and reduce the risk some diseases including cancer
One rationale behind fasting reducing the risk of cancer and potentially other chronic diseases is that fasting lowers insulin and insulin-like growth factor, high levels of which have been linked to cancer. Reducing these hormones may slow cancer cell growth and development. Animal studies have shown that IER inhibits and can even reverse the growth of a variety of tumors, including neuroblastoma, ovarian, and breast cancer.3
Studies are ongoing looking at these various methods of fasting, and it is likely that there is not a “one-size-fits-all approach,” but rather to see what is most realistic and feasible for the individual. For some, limiting intake to a specified time window may work, while for others, caloric restriction (<500 calories/day) a few days a week or skipping breakfast and lunch a few days a week may be more achievable. Personally, I have a hard time eating dinner before 7-8 pm but could certainly skip breakfast a few days a week (and maybe lunch, over time!).
There are still many questions that need to be answered before making widespread recommendations regarding fasting, but as the authors of this study point out, this might be a simple, nonpharmacologic way to reduce risk of breast cancer recurrence and potentially other chronic diseases.
- Dhurandhar EJ, Dawson J, Alcorn A, et al. The effectiveness of breakfast recommendations on weight loss: A randomized controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr. 2014;100(2):507—513.
- Lee C, Raffaghello L, Brandhorst S, et al. Fasting cycles retard growth of tumors and sensitize a range of cancer cell types to chemotherapy. Sci Transl Med. 2012;4(124):124-127.